BEST HOME BUILDERS

The Best Home Builders on Florida's Gulf Coast

Are you looking for the best home builders in Florida's Gulf Coast? If you're ready to buy a brand-new home and want to know which builders offer the best quality, customization, and design, you've come to the right place. After receiving numerous questions about top-rated home builders, we've compiled a list of the best options available in Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch, and beyond.

1. Toll Brothers

Toll Brothers is known as America's luxury builder, developing high-end communities nationwide, including several in Southwest Florida. In Sarasota, they are currently building in three locations:

• The Isles at Lakewood Ranch – Located off University Parkway, offering a mix of elegance and convenience.

• Monterey – A great option for those who prefer more privacy and unique home designs.

• Solstice at Wellen Park – A master-planned community with resort-style amenities.

Toll Brothers homes feature beautifully designed neighborhoods with clubhouses, resort pools, dog parks, and fitness centers, making them an excellent choice for those seeking a luxurious lifestyle.

2. Lee Wetherington Homes

With over 40 years of experience, Lee Wetherington is a well-respected builder in Sarasota and Manatee County. Their homes are known for:

• Customization, ensuring no two homes look alike.

• Expansive patios and lanais, ideal for indoor-outdoor Florida living.

• High-end finishes and quality craftsmanship.

They are currently building in Wild Blue (starting at $2 million), Everly at Wellen Park, Shellstone, The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch, and Sanctuary Cove in Bradenton. Additionally, Lee Wetherington offers custom home-building services for those with their own lot.

3. David Weekley Homes

David Weekley Homes is a high-end national builder that has been expanding in Sarasota and Lakewood Ranch. Their key advantages include:

• Energy-efficient and sustainable building practices.

• Award-winning customer service.

• Functional and innovative floor plans.

They are currently building in Emerald Landing at Lakewood Ranch, The Estuary in North Venice, and Gracewater in Sarasota. Their homes offer an alternative to production builders like Pulte or Taylor Morrison while maintaining competitive pricing.

4. Sam Rodgers Homes

A lesser-known but highly respected builder, Sam Rodgers has been crafting homes for over 50 years. Their communities feature timeless designs and superior craftsmanship. Current projects include:

• Grand Place at Wellen Park – Spacious homes with large outdoor living areas.

• Stonebridge at Palmer Ranch – A rare opportunity to own a new home in this sought-after area.

• Arbor Lake Preserve – A gated community with upcoming amenities, located east of I-75.

Sam Rodgers Homes cater to those looking for beautifully appointed homes in boutique-style neighborhoods.

5. Neal Signature Homes

As the luxury division of Neal Homes, Neal Signature focuses on well-appointed residences in intimate settings. They specialize in finding scenic locations with lush nature and picturesque views. Current projects include:

• The Alcove at Waterside in Lakewood Ranch

• Waterbury in Lakewood Ranch

• Everly at Wellen Park

• Tide Line in Bradenton – A new community near Palma Sola with coastal-style homes.

Neal Signature Homes are perfect for buyers seeking high-end homes in smaller, more private communities.

6. Homes by Town

With a legacy spanning over 75 years, Homes by Town is a reputable builder known for creating stunning homes in prime locations. They are the primary builder in Lakehouse Cove and are now expanding to Shellstone, with homes starting at around $1 million.

Their floor plans range from 2,200 to 2,600 square feet, offering spacious backyards, large lanais, and a signature coastal feel that blends beautifully with Florida’s outdoor lifestyle.

7. Homes by West Bay

Originally established in the Tampa area, Homes by West Bay has expanded into Sarasota and Lakewood Ranch. They offer high-end homes at competitive price points, making luxury living more attainable.

They are currently building in:

• Star Farms at Lakewood Ranch

• Everly at Wellen Park

Homes by West Bay is known for its spacious layouts, upscale finishes, and affordability compared to other luxury builders in the region.

Which Home Builder is Right for You?

Each of these builders offers something unique, whether it's high-end customization, sustainable building practices, or affordable luxury. If you're looking for a well-built, thoughtfully designed home in Sarasota or Lakewood Ranch, these builders are some of the best options available.

For more details on any of these home builders or to schedule a tour, feel free to reach out. We’d love to help you find the perfect home in Florida’s Gulf Coast!