Discover Sarasota’s Hidden Gem Neighborhoods: Your Guide to Finding the Perfect Home

When it comes to finding the perfect neighborhood in Sarasota, it’s all about uncovering those hidden gems that offer unique charm, beauty, and lifestyle. Today, we’re diving into five stunning neighborhoods tucked away but offering everything you could want in a Sarasota home. Stick around because my favorite neighborhood is saved for last!

Sapphire Shores

Located west of Tamiami Trail and north of downtown Sarasota, Sapphire Shores is an eclectic and older neighborhood characterized by its massive trees and private, quaint streets. This hidden gem is close to Ringling College of Art and Design, the Ringling Museum, and just five minutes from downtown Sarasota. Nestled along the Sarasota Bayfront, it offers a serene yet convenient location that many people might overlook.

Hidden Oaks

If you dream of Old Florida charm, Hidden Oaks is the place to be. This neighborhood, located off Bahia Vista between Honore and McIntosh, is known for its majestic oak trees and spacious lots—each home sits on over an acre of land. With a variety of architectural styles, from modern to traditional, Hidden Oaks is perfect for those who value space and a sense of community. It’s close to downtown and the beaches, making it ideal for those who love outdoor activities and a peaceful, fulfilling lifestyle.

Highlights of Hidden Oaks:

  • Regulation tennis courts for both casual and competitive play.
  • Privately owned roads perfect for biking, jogging, and walking.
  • Deed-restricted community ensuring high standards and aesthetic integrity.

Philippi Gardens

Established almost 50 years ago, Philippi Gardens is the most affordable neighborhood on our list, offering waterfront properties with deep water access to the intercoastal waterways, Sarasota Bay, and the Gulf of Mexico. This neighborhood features over 600 homes with unique designs, winding streets, and mature trees. It’s a popular choice for boating enthusiasts and those who appreciate the convenience of nearby amenities.

Key Features of Philippi Gardens:

  • Average home price: Under $800,000.
  • Waterfront living: Ideal for kayakers, boaters, and fishermen.
  • Local attractions: Philippi Creek Village Restaurant and Oyster Bar, Philippi State Park.


Imagine Sarasota 100 years ago, and you’ll find yourself in Avondale, a neighborhood developed in the early 1920s. With towering oak trees and homes dating back to the 1920s, Avondale is a historic neighborhood filled with charm. Located west of Tamiami Trail, it’s close to Sarasota downtown, hospitals, the Bayfront, and several cultural attractions like Selby Botanical Gardens and Sarasota Modern Art Museum.

Reasons to Love Avondale:

  • Historic charm: Homes from the 1920s, 1950s, and new builds.
  • Prime location: Close to downtown, shopping, and dining.
  • Scenic beauty: Lush, mature landscaping and historic architecture.

Bay Island

Last but certainly not least, Bay Island is one of Sarasota’s finest neighborhoods. Located on the way to Siesta Key, this enclave offers luxury homes with breathtaking views of Sarasota Bay or Roberts Bay. With prices ranging from $1.5 million to $6.7 million, Bay Island redefines island living with its spacious estates and stunning scenery.

What Makes Bay Island Special:

  • Waterfront views: Many homes offer panoramic bay views.
  • Proximity to beaches: Just minutes from Siesta Key Beach and Siesta Village.
  • Architectural diversity: Featuring colonial, modern, and traditional beach bungalow styles.


Whether you’re drawn to the historic charm of Avondale, the spacious lots of Hidden Oaks, or the luxury of Bay Island, Sarasota has a hidden gem neighborhood perfect for you. Explore these neighborhoods and find the perfect place to call home in beautiful Sarasota.

If you’re looking to buy, sell, or invest in real estate in Sarasota or Manatee counties, my team and I at Sarasota Neighborhood Experts are here to help. Contact us today and let’s find your dream home in one of Sarasota’s hidden gems!

Check out this article next

The Truth About Florida Condos: What You Need to Know

The Truth About Florida Condos: What You Need to Know

Are you considering purchasing a condo in Florida but find yourself bombarded with negativity? It's easy to find horror stories online, but the reality is…

Read Article